Monday 23 January 2017

Jason Kenney Town Hall, 01-19-2017 (the 2500 word version)

As part of Jason Kenney's Unite Alberta Tour/Progressive Conservative Leadership Campaign, he arranged numerous events around the province.  This event was on January 19, 2017 in Calgary.

Dave Rodney spoke first to reiterate his endorsement of Jason Kenney for leader of the PC party.  “This has been done before,” he began, “Lougheed united the right and the centre right and it is time to unite Progressive Conservatives and the Wildrose Party.  The NDP are destroying the Albertan way of life” he declared, though his emotion was lost in the weak audio connection, “we need to bring back the Alberta Advantage… and unite with Jason Kenney!”  This strong sentiment brought an awkward attempt at a standing ovation which did not make it to the back half of the room. 

When Jason Kenney took the stage, he talked about the last two weeks and how 900 people had shown up at the previous town hall in Calgary.  “We want our province back” he said as forcefully as the poor audio would allow.  “We are united in a belief in hard work and personal responsibility; Albertans believe in the creative power of free enterprise;  an idea that you work hard and achieve some of your dreams to pass it on for a better way of life.  Alberta has some of the most compassionate people in this country and the NDP doesn’t understand that, doesn’t understand Albertans, or our way of life.  We need to stand up together, for our Alberta.”

He then digressed into the personal stories of Albertans from his summer pre-campaign campaigning across the province, beginning with a half-truth about how he started that.  “A few months ago” he stated, “I left my job as a federal MP, my only income, to begin a campaign for unity across the province.  I started a movement in Alberta; revived hope and optimism.”  Perhaps his memory is a little fuzzy with these details.  He did resign on September 20, 2016 but his provincial tour began in July of 2016.  For collecting a federal pay cheque while he campaigned for a new job, Kenney took heat from Albertans, Conservatives and the Canadian Taxpayers Federation, his only job prior to becoming a federal MP.

“Albertans are uniting” he claimed, and he would know because he was out there.  He told us that “as the NDP came to office, Albertans were leaving for BC and Saskatchewan" He talked about the people he’d met, most of whom were the ages of those in the room (I had the average age of autonomous attendees estimated at about 57 years).  The 54 year old woman who lost her job and was working in a role she would have had when she was in her 20’s.  The crowd was appropriately affected, murmuring and shaking their heads.   The ‘young couple’ from Calgary who had owned a business for 32 years and who “survived the NEP but couldn’t survive the NDP”.  He chuckled and there was more head shaking; they remember.  I don't. 

There was a 17 year old boy from Hardisty who now realized that “politics has consequences” but was clueless how government or elections worked.  He was running up to Jason at a gas station yelling “Hey! Are you that Kenney guy?!” (because he’s 17 and that’s how kids talk?) And he asked Jason how quickly he would be in government to stop the NDP.  Jason had to explain that he couldn’t do it right away and this young man replied “why, why will it take so long?” This young man told Jason that his father had lost his job in the oil patch and couldn’t find work.  As a result, this young boy was supporting his parents and his four siblings.  Jason called him an oilfield worker later on in the story but I can’t say whether he mixed up the father and the son or if the 17 year old was also an oilfield worker.

“Alberta has gone so far off track” he lamented, “we’ve gotten through before but this time it’s different.  This NDP government is determined to make a bad decision worse. They have no mandate to make everything more expensive. Moms and dads, who lost their jobs or have 70% lower income, these are the people taxes will hit the hardest.”  As to the environmental gain; “there is none” he told the crowd.  Without naming him, Kenney spoke of a University of Alberta professor's (Andrew Leach) comment that in order to make a difference, carbon would have to be taxed at $200 per tonne rather than $30 per tonne. 

The audio was finally fixed and we could hear much better. “We are the only major oil and gas producing country in the world to have a carbon tax” he told the crowd, “we want to vote on the carbon tax!”  Further regulations, like Bill 6, are also ruining people in Alberta.  He spoke of a family from Grande Prairie who “sold all their heads and the farm” because of the “administrative work” imposed on them by the NDP[i].


Kenney claimed “the NDP wants to bring Ontario’s Environmental Plan to Alberta” and nodded to a Fraser Institute study as evidence; he didn’t identify which study, just “a” study.  “Does this government care,” he asked the crowd “they have no regard for the people, they only have their ideology.”  And the crowd mumbled in agreement.  “There are 2300 new coal plants being built around the world.  We need to attract industries to Alberta but these industries are reliant on power."  Those industries will not come here, he told us, and that will create less diversity in our economy, not more.

He then spoke about Trudeau’s latest gaffe of saying that the oilsands need to be phased out.  Of course, Harper said the same thing a few years ago but he elaborated and Trudeau did not; therefore the latter is nefarious while the former is... a conservative.  Kenney claimed the demand for oil was to exceed 4 trillion dollars over the next few years and suggested Trudeau was forcing Alberta to not be a major contributor.  The crowd liked it.

“We all hope some innovation comes along someday that will reduce our dependency on fossil fuels” he surprised me by saying “but until that day, we need a premier who will stand up to the Prime Minister; like the person everyone wishes was Alberta’s premier, Brad Wall.”  This statement received some cheers.  Of course, they want Brad Wall as a mascot but no Albertan wants his sales tax or higher income taxes or crumbling roads. 

Next, Kenney moved on to education and the audience was ripe.  “This government has proposed a radical review” he said sadly “with a goal to turn students into ‘effective agents of change’” (emphasis his) and the crowd booed. “We know what that means, don’t we?” He eyed the crowd and spoke the dreaded word.... “Activism”… and people shook their heads and the sound of muffled discontent filled the room[ii] .  “They’re working on a secret curriculum” he pronounced “one that doesn’t involve moms and dads.  Our kids need education, not pedagogical fads.”  He believes the NDP has “caused damage to the structure of the economy and the political culture, not just in Alberta, but Canada”.  As evidence, he introduced the next topic; Saskatchewan in 1944.

“Go Riders!” He shouted and a few people cheered but most were.. shocked?  After all, the town hall was being held in Calgary, directly across the street from McMahon Stadium. “Go Stampeders!” A woman called back from my side of the room and the crowd loudly agreed.   The mood was lighter afterwards and he asked how many were “displaced” Saskatchewanians like himself.  There were a few, certainly, but not enough to make him feel like he was talking to a room full of sympathizers.

“In 1944, Saskatchewan’s population was over a million and Alberta’s was half that, now Alberta is over 4 million and Saskatchewan has less than a million” he began  “The population decreased when the CCF in Saskatchewan raised taxes and chased away investors.  Oil companies picked up as one and moved everything to Calgary.” [iii] It was after the province was able to “unite through the Saskatchewan Party” (2007) that the economy turned around he claims. [iv]  “Drilling is down in Alberta and unemployment is up”[v] in comparison to Saskatchewan, “like Brad Wall said, this is no time for a six decade experiment with the NDP. We need to get our Alberta back.”

There are divisions between the parties he said, and he has “great respect for Lougheed, Klein and the Alberta Advantage… but you have to admit the PC party got off course.  There was a word to describe the PC party and that was ‘arrogant’.  Half of the PC supporters went to the Wildrose party” he claimed.  And then there was some genuine excitement. 

A gentleman stood up and started to yelling “Don’t you put words in my mouth! I’m a Wildrose supporter … don’t say things about the Wildrose!”  I confess to missing exactly what set him off as I was writing when I realized there was a disruption.  The crowd wasn’t having it.  “Sit down! No one asked you! Go home!” they yelled.  The anger was swift and loud and, frankly, a little unnerving.  The gentleman was escorted away even though Kenney invited him to ask his questions after the speech.

Kenney picked up where he’d left off although it was obvious the crowd was a little distracted; a din was making it difficult to hear him for a few minutes.  “If there is not a united party in 2019, the NDP wins” he said, “if we can do it federally, we can do it provincially to save Alberta… uniting was infinitely harder to do federally, but we did it in 10 months and won the next three elections”[vi] .  “The Wildrose party said it was open to a merger; it was the PC Party that showed no interest”[vii]

He finished off by saying that he “will support any other leader” the membership decides to elect.  People need to show “humility, park their egos, avoid labels and emotions and focus on the future”.   The crowd clapped; some stood, many did not, and people began to line up for questions.

1. The first gentleman up to the microphone for a question was a young man who had lost his job.  He asked Kenney what he would do to restore the Alberta Advantage.  Kenney replied that he would “put Alberta first and renew Alberta as a beacon of opportunity”.

2. The second gentleman was wearing a “Make America Great Again” hat.  He asked how Kenney would fix what the NDP has done in the province.  “I will reverse taxes and bureaucracy; when I defeat the NDP I will extend the legislature into the summer to repeal the regressive policies.  Bill 1 will repeal the carbon tax and other pieces of legislation and regulation. Once we have united, we’ll be able to slow down the NDP.  Their preferred path to power is that we remain divided so they only have to compete for 35% of the vote.  If we end the vote split they will have to compete for 40-45%.   We need to slow down the damage they are doing.”

3.  What will you do about education and the social engineering in our schools? “I respect parental rights and their authority in education.  They have a prior right to direct the education of their children.  The NDP picks and chooses; school choice respects rights of parents.  The NDP wants to undermine these rights and undo our tradition of pluralism in education.”

4. Is the little group of MLAs in Edmonton with you?  “Four out of the six MLAs available to endorse me have done so.”

5. Alberta has changed over the past 30 years.  Do you have a more centrist message for those who are not far right?  “It will be a big tent party full of tolerant, diverse individuals.  I’ve never used the term ‘Unite the Right’.  A free-enterprise party will create wealth; family is most important; respect for educational choice. The party will be an unhyphenated party like what Stephen Harper created.   A coalition with different views; what unites you, not what divides you.  That’s what Steph- that’s what Lougheed did.”

6.  What policies will you adopt from the Wildrose party? “There was too much top-down in the PC party of the past.  The membership will tell us what they want.  I don’t want to put my own opinions out there.  We need to focus on democratic reform and unity.”

7. Regarding oil development, Lougheed wanted to protect the environment and the water and Klein was a proponent of nuclear energy.  Where do you stand on that? “I stand for environmental protection and prudent, responsible and affordable measures on greenhouse gases but not at a cost.  Other jurisdictions are not doing it.  The rest of the world is investing in 2300 coal fired plants.  We should focus on technology, research and development like Brad Wall.  We don’t expel enough greenhouse gases; bring on the technology.”

8. Is it your goal to minimize the progressive wing? “The party will be inclusive and broad, a party of free enterprise supporters. When we united the Conservative Party of Canada, we lost a marginal amount of support from the extreme sides.  Some Progressive Conservatives will find they’re more comfortable with the NDP, right? (Laughter). The majority, though, will stay.  If I get a mandate on March 18, some will leave and they’ll get a lot of press, but the 20-30,000 that stay will get no press.”

9.  I support your platform.  I was a teacher for 30 years and a high school principal.  On the subject of parental rights, I believe parents are responsible as first educators in their child’s life and there is a role for politicians to ensure a place for all kids.  I want to ask about the act for safe and caring schools for kids, Bill 10.  Will a united conservative party under your leadership ensure GSA’s are upheld? “Yes” Will a united conservative party under your leadership balance between parents and politicians? “I do not believe a politician should be involved in that.” Will a united conservative party under your leadership promote socially progressive ideas? “Yes. For example, while I was a member of the federal party, I supported tax cuts, Guaranteed Income Supplement and the Child and Family Benefits.  A compassionate conservative party can create wealth; it creates wealth to help those and need.”

He told a story about an autistic child in Grande Prairie who, after learning about gender, became confused about her identity; gender dysphasia, he called it.  This child enlisted assistance from the school and was being treated as a boy and even being called a boy’s name while at school.   The parents were not informed of this.  (After an hour and a half of google searches, I could find nothing to corroborate this story; if you find anything, please share and I will update with a reference).

10.  Kids are getting a $100 cheque in the mail and they think it’s “cool”.  Why would they vote for you?  “Because they’ll be mugged by economic reality.  It’s the false promise of the NDP; they create a base of voters who think the NDP is okay.”

11.  Hi, I’m nine years old and I’m in grade 4.  My teacher told me that the oil sands are bad (shocked crowd) I went home and talked to my parents and they told me the oil sands are good and that they give people jobs.  (Loud applause) How…. how will you convince people like my friends? We all trust my teacher.  (More loud applause and compliments from Kenney on her intelligence and bravery).  “We should have teachers with no bias who will let you figure out what’s right and wrong.  We need to get politics out of the classroom.”

12. I’m her mother (to applause). I just want to say that you have to say no to brainwashing.  You need to instill your own values in your kids.

Michelle Rempel was invited to the podium next and she didn’t seem to have the room’s attention.  Many people were leaving and it was difficult to focus on her.  She didn’t manage to rile up the crowd at all and then she was gone.

The woman beside me asked me if what the young girl said had upset me.  I said it looked like a shameless plant and I was disgusted.  She agreed it was probably planted.  We talked a bit about sharing values with your children and talking to them about what they learn in school.  They were pleasant, she and her husband and their adult daughter.  They were Mormons he said, "so we're very conservative."  They were not sure if they supported this path forward yet and that’s why they’d attended tonight.  They hadn’t heard enough to make a decision.   




[ii] The quote “effective agents of change” can be found in a competency model for Alberta Education; “CULTURAL AND GLOBAL CITIZENSHIP involves actively engaging with cultural, environmental, political or economic systems. Students acknowledge First Nations, Métis, Inuit, Francophone or other perspectives when taking action on local or global issues. They advocate for the dignity and well-being of individuals and communities. Students value equity and diversity, and believe in their capacity to make a difference”; an indicator of which is “valuing equity and diversity and believing in the capacity to make a difference” followed by “Examples: • I acknowledge that I am an agent of change. • I balance the need for both equity and diversity in communities.” Page 8 https://education.alberta.ca/media/3272998/competency-indicators-september-30-2016.pdf

[iii] Nothing could be found in searches of economic history in the area to corroborate this statement.  Fun fact: the largest oil production company in Saskatchewan is the Federated Co-op; a unionized, socialist venture. https://www.coopconnection.ca/wps/wcm/connect/83e6cd9c-f018-43d7-83c2-730c9b9b9fbb/FCL-Annual-Report-2014.pdf?MOD=AJPERES

[iv]In recent years, Saskatchewan's agricultural and mineral resources have come into new demand, and it has entered a new period of strong economic growth” cited from an archived RBC economic report, 2007.

[v] Alberta and Saskatchewan GDP looks very similar, but the employment rates show the difference. In January 2017 Alberta's workforce looked like this: In Goods Producing sector: 8% Agriculture, 25% Forestry, Mining and Oil and Gas, 3% Utilities. 43% construction and 18% manufacturing. The same sectors in Saskatchewan: 25% Agriculture, 16% Forestry, Mining and Oil and Gas, 3% Utilities, 32% construction and 18% manufacturing. The only difference was found in Saskatchewan from the previous January; manufacturing increased from 16%, construction decreased from 35%  and agriculture decreased from 26%. https://www.saskatchewan.ca/business/invest-and-economic-development/exporting-and-trade https://www.albertacanada.com/files/albertacanada/SP-EH_highlightsABEconomyPresentation.pdf
http://www.statcan.gc.ca/tables-tableaux/sum-som/l01/cst01/labr67i-eng.htm
http://www.statcan.gc.ca/tables-tableaux/sum-som/l01/cst01/labr67j-eng.htm 

[vi] The newly-formed CPC lost the election in 2003 to the Liberals; won a minority in 2006, a larger minority in 2008, a majority in 2011 and lost it in 2015; that’s not exactly a stellar record. http://thisweekinabpolitics.blogspot.ca/2017/01/the-saga-is-still-ongoing.html

No comments:

Post a Comment